skip to primary navigationskip to content
 

Political Thought, Time and History: An International Conference

POLITICAL THOUGHT, TIME, AND HISTORY

An International Conference

Clare College, University of Cambridge

Thursday 10 and Friday 11 May 2018

Registration to open shortly

It is easy to assume that political thought is bound up with time and history.  To most historians, time and history are obvious dimensions of politics; politics occur in contexts which are temporal and historical, and must be studied by reference to the evidence provided by those contexts.  Periodically historians have questioned whether temporality should be regarded as uniform; recently, there has been much interest in the thesis that ‘modernity’ entailed a new understanding of time.  But whether that understanding, and the understandings of time in pre-modern eras, are thought of as belonging to contemporaries and shared by all those who thought about politics, or are conceived rather as heuristic models, is often unclear.  The debate hovers uncertainly between intellectual history and historical methodology. 

Political philosophers, however, have never taken time and history for granted.  Whether temporality is a necessary or normative foundation for the concept of the civitas, the state, whether political concepts require to be inserted into a historical narrative to be effective are questions to which they have returned very different answers.  A Machiavelli might hold politics governed by an inherently temporal ‘necessity’, and insist that political agency be assessed in its specific historical outcomes.  But a Hobbes or a Rousseau would create a foundation for the state which deliberately limited the scope for time to make a difference, and which would be valid independent of historical circumstance.  A similar division may be found among the jurists.  Exponents of customary law argued from prescription, while Roman jurists explored the adaptability of concepts codified for the inhabitants of the Roman Empire to the post-Roman world of multiple kingdoms and city-states.  But other jurists set aside time by preferring first principles to prescription, or by making historical examples support accounts of natural law as the universal, supratemporal embodiment of civilised sociability.  Viewed as the study of ‘languages’, the history of political thought has found itself studying many languages to which time and history are essential – but many too which diminish or exclude them.  

The aim of this conference will be to explore the variety of engagements with time and history found in political thinkers, the better to understand (and, perhaps, to explain) why political philosophy has been unable to take these concepts for granted.  Themes of individual sessions will include Time and the State, the temporal and historical perspectives available to political thinkers following the fall of the Roman Empire, time in customary and Roman legal traditions, the temporalities of civil and sacred history in the early modern period, the conceptual status of Enlightenment ‘stadial history’ and what it contributed to the understanding of society and government, the time of ‘modern’ politics, in the nineteenth and again in the twentieth centuries, and whether a political thought ‘global’ in time and history is conceivable.  It will end with a reassessment of time in the history of political thought itself: what understandings of time should govern our engagement with the political and legal thought of the past, whether remote or still close at hand?  Must they be adapted if the history of political thought is, as many of its foremost practitioners have hoped, to enhance political philosophy itself?  The conference is organised under the aegis of the Cambridge Centre for Political Thought and the University’s Faculty of History.

Programme

 

Thursday 10 May

0930 – 1100:  The state in time and history

Quentin Skinner (Queen Mary, London), ‘Why states need time’

Christopher Clark (Cambridge),  ‘The times of power’

 

1100 – 1130: Coffee

 

1130 – 1300:  Political understandings of time and history after the Roman Empire

Caroline Humfress (St Andrews), ‘Out of time? Eternal judgements in late antiquity’     

David D’Avray (UCL), ‘Medieval political thought as a social system in time’      

 

1300 – 1415:  Lunch

 

1415 – 1545:   Time and history in the Customary and Roman legal traditions

George Garnett (Oxford), ‘The logic of authority and the logic of evidence’                  

Magnus Ryan (Cambridge), ‘Historicity and universality in the political thought of medieval Roman Lawyers’

 

1545 – 1615: Tea

 

1615 – 1745:  Civil (‘Politick’) and Sacred History in the early modern period

Kinch Hoekstra (Berkeley),  ‘Politic History’          

Sarah Mortimer (Oxford), ‘The commonwealth and Christian time’

 

Friday 11 May

0930 – 1100:  Enlightenment stadial histories of ‘society’

Aaron Garrett (Boston),  ‘Scottish time’

Silvia Sebastiani (EHESS, Paris), 'Civilisation and perfectibility: conflicting views of the history of humankind?'

 

1100 – 1130:  Coffee

                       

1130 – 1300:  The time of ‘modern’ politics and law

Chris Meckstroth (Cambridge),  ‘A revolution in time: German Idealism on the future and the past’

Charlotte Johann (Cambridge), 'Rethinking politics through the history of law: the German Historical School contra Hegelianism’

 

1300 – 1415:  Lunch              

 

1415 – 1545:  The time of politics in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries

Aline-Florence Manent (Queen Mary, London), ‘Of time and timeliness: Pragmatism in Postwar German political thought’                 

Shruti Kapila (Cambridge), ‘The time of global political thought’

 

1545 – 1615:  Tea

 

1615 – 1730:  Panel: How then should we understand time in the History of Political Thought?

Annabel Brett (Cambridge)                             

Megan Donaldson (Cambridge)

Dina Gusejnova (Sheffield)

Sylvana Tomaselli (Chair, Cambridge)

A major conference on this theme will be held under the auspices of the Centre for Political Thought at Clare College, Cambridge, on 10-11 May 2018. The conference will address the ways in which political philosophers have engaged with concepts of time and the evidence of history. Registration details will be available here shortly.

Read More

A CRASSH conference bringing together intellectual historians and political theorists to explore the role of elites in democratic thought, from the founding figures of 'elite theory' to the present. The event will chart the trajectory of this political dilemma from its inception in the late-nineteenth/early-twentieth century to today’s crises. Registration is open.

Read more

Interventions | The Intellectual History Podcast

A brand new intellectual history podcast by grad students at Cambridge. Interventions introduces intellectual historians and their work to everyone with an interest in history and politics.